Changing and restoring state

It’s dangerous to change state

Whenever possible, it is desirable to write so-called pure functions. The property we focus on here is that the function should not change the surrounding R landscape, i.e. it should not change things like the search path, global options, or the working directory. If the behaviour of other functions differs before and after running your function, you’ve modified the landscape. Changing the landscape is bad because it makes code much harder to understand.

Here’s a sloppy() function that prints a number with a specific number of significant digits, by adjusting R’s global “digits” option.

sloppy <- function(x, sig_digits) {
  options(digits = sig_digits)
  print(x)
}

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

sloppy(pi, 2)
#> [1] 3.1

pi
#> [1] 3.1

Notice how pi prints differently before and after the call to sloppy()? Calling sloppy() has a side effect: it changes the “digits” option globally, not just within its own scope of operations. This is what we want to avoid.

Don’t worry, we’re restoring global state (specifically, the “digits” option) behind the scenes here.

Sometimes you cannot avoid modifying the state of the world, in which case you just have to make sure that you put things back the way you found them. This is what the withr package is for.

The base solution: on.exit()

The first function to know about is base R’s on.exit(). Inside your function body, every time you do something that should be undone on exit, you immediately register the cleanup code with on.exit(expr, add = TRUE)¹.

neat() is an improvement over sloppy(), because it uses on.exit() to ensure that the “digits” option is restored to its original value.

neat <- function(x, sig_digits) {
  op <- options(digits = sig_digits)
  on.exit(options(op), add = TRUE)
  print(x)
}

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

neat(pi, 2)
#> [1] 3.1

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

on.exit() also works when you exit the function abnormally, i.e. due to error. This is why official tools, like on.exit(), are a better choice than any do-it-yourself solution to this problem.

on.exit() is a very useful function, but it’s not very flexible. The withr package provides an extensible on.exit()-inspired toolkit.

defer() is the foundation of withr

defer() is the core function of withr and is very much like on.exit(), i.e. it schedules the execution of arbitrary code when the current function exits:

neater <- function(x, sig_digits) {
  op <- options(digits = sig_digits)
  defer(options(op))
  print(x)
}

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

neater(pi, 2)
#> [1] 3.1

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

withr::defer() is basically a drop-in substitute for on.exit(), but with three key differences we explore below:

1. Different default behaviour around the effect of a series of two or more calls
2. Control over the environment the deferred events are associated with
3. Ability to work with the global environment

Here we focus on using withr inside your functions. See the blog post Self-cleaning test fixtures or the testthat vignette Test fixtures for how to use withr inside tests.

Last-in, first-out

If you make more than one call to defer(), by default, it adds expressions to the top of the stack of deferred actions.

defer_stack <- function() {
  cat("put on socks\n")
  defer(cat("take off socks\n"))
  
  cat("put on shoes\n")
  defer(cat("take off shoes\n"))
}
defer_stack()
#> put on socks
#> put on shoes
#> take off shoes
#> take off socks

In contrast, by default, a subsequent call to on.exit() overwrites the deferred actions registered in the previous call.

on_exit_last_one_wins <- function() {
  cat("put on socks\n")
  on.exit(cat("take off socks\n"))
  
  cat("put on shoes\n")
  on.exit(cat("take off shoes\n"))
}
on_exit_last_one_wins()
#> put on socks
#> put on shoes
#> take off shoes

Oops, we still have our socks on! The last-in, first-out, stack-like behaviour of defer() tends to be what you want in most applications.

To get such behaviour with on.exit(), remember to call it with add = TRUE, after = FALSE².

on_exit_stack <- function() {
  cat("put on socks\n")
  on.exit(cat("take off socks\n"), add = TRUE, after = FALSE)
  
  cat("put on shoes\n")
  on.exit(cat("take off shoes\n"), add = TRUE, after = FALSE)
}
on_exit_stack()
#> put on socks
#> put on shoes
#> take off shoes
#> take off socks

Conversely, if you want defer() to have first-in, first-out behaviour, specify priority = "last".

defer_queue <- function() {
  cat("Adam gets in line for ice cream\n")
  defer(cat("Adam gets ice cream\n"), priority = "last")

  cat("Beth gets in line for ice cream\n")
  defer(cat("Beth gets ice cream\n"), priority = "last")
}
defer_queue()
#> Adam gets in line for ice cream
#> Beth gets in line for ice cream
#> Adam gets ice cream
#> Beth gets ice cream

“Local” functions (and “with” functions)

Both on.exit() and withr::defer() schedule actions to be executed when a certain environment goes out of scope, most typically the execution environment of a function. But the envir argument of withr::defer() lets you specify a different environment, which makes it possible to create customised on.exit() extensions.

Let’s look at the neater() function again.

neater <- function(x, sig_digits) {
  op <- options(digits = sig_digits) # record orig. "digits" & change "digits"
  defer(options(op))                 # schedule restoration of "digits"
  
  print(x)
}

The first two lines are typical on.exit() maneuvers where, in some order, you record an original state, arrange for its eventual restoration, and change it. In real life, this can be much more involved and you might want to wrap this logic up into a helper function. You can’t wrap on.exit() in this way, because there’s no way to reach back up into the correct parent frame and schedule cleanup there. But with defer(), we can! Here is such a custom helper, called local_digits().

local_digits <- function(sig_digits, envir = parent.frame()) {
  op <- options(digits = sig_digits)
  defer(options(op), envir = envir)
}

We can use local_digits() to keep any manipulation of digits local to a function.

neato <- function(x, digits) {
  local_digits(digits)
  print(x)
}

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

neato(pi, 2)
#> [1] 3.1

neato(pi, 4)
#> [1] 3.142

You can even call local_digits() multiple times inside a function. Each call to local_digits() is in effect until the next or until the function exits, which ever comes first.

neatful <- function(x) {
  local_digits(1)
  print(x)
  local_digits(3)
  print(x)
  local_digits(5)
  print(x)
}

neatful(pi)
#> [1] 3
#> [1] 3.14
#> [1] 3.1416

Certain state changes, such as modifying global options, come up so often that withr offers pre-made helpers. These helpers come in two forms: local_*() functions, like the one we just made, and with_*() functions, which we explain below. Here are the state change helpers in withr that you are most likely to find useful:

We didn’t really need to write our own local_digits() helper, because the built-in withr::local_options() also gets the job done:

neatest <- function(x, sig_digits) {
  local_options(list(digits = sig_digits))
  print(x)
}

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

neatest(pi, 2)
#> [1] 3.1

neatest(pi, 4)
#> [1] 3.142

The local_*() functions target a slightly different use case from the with_*() functions, which are inspired by base R’s with() function:

• with_*() functions are best for executing a small snippet of code with a modified state

  neat_with <- function(x, sig_digits) {
    # imagine lots of code here
    withr::with_options(
      list(digits = sig_digits),
      print(x)
    )
    # ... and a lot more code here
  }

• local_*() functions are best for modifying state “from now until the function exits”

  neat_local <- function(x, sig_digits) {
    withr::local_options(list(digits = sig_digits))
    print(x)
    # imagine lots of code here
  }

It’s best to minimize the footprint of your state modifications. Therefore, use with_*() functions where you can. But when this forces you to put lots of (indented) code inside with_*(), e.g. most of your function’s body, then it’s better to use local_*().

Deferring events on the global environment

Here is one last difference between withr::defer() and on.exit(): the ability to defer events on the global environment³.

At first, it sounds pretty weird to propose scheduling deferred actions on the global environment. It’s not ephemeral, the way function execution environments are. It goes out of scope very rarely, i.e. when you exit R. Why would you want this?

The answer is: for development purposes.

If you are developing functions or tests that use withr, it’s very useful to be able to execute that code interactively, without error, and with the ability to trigger the deferred events. It’s hard to develop with functions that work one way inside a function, but another way in the global environment (or, worse, throw an error).

Here’s how defer() (and all functions based on it) works in an interactive session.

library(withr)

defer(print("hi"))
#> Setting deferred event(s) on global environment.
#>   * Execute (and clear) with `withr::deferred_run()`.
#>   * Clear (without executing) with `withr::deferred_clear()`.

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

# this adds another deferred event, but does not re-message
local_digits(3)

pi
#> [1] 3.14

deferred_run()
#> [1] "hi"

pi
#> [1] 3.141593

When you defer events on the global environment, you get a message that alerts you to the situation. If you add subsequent events, the message is not repeated. Since the global environment isn’t perishable, like a test environment is, you have to call deferred_run() explicitly to execute the deferred events. You can also clear them, without running, with deferred_clear().